Two Types — and It Matters
There are two kinds. Ionization detectors contain a tiny sealed source of radioactive Americium-241 (look for an 'I' or the word 'ionization,' or a radiation symbol, on the back). Photoelectric detectors use a light sensor and contain no radioactive material. The type determines disposal: photoelectric and carbon-monoxide detectors are handled as electronics/e-waste or per local trash rules, while ionization units are best routed to a manufacturer take-back or a household hazardous waste (HHW) program.
Are They Dangerous? (No, If Intact)
Barely radioactive and safe to handle. Most ionization detectors contain one microcurie or less of Am-241, sealed inside a foil-and-ceramic chamber. The EPA states there's no health threat as long as the detector isn't damaged and is used as directed, and the NRC calculates a household with two detectors receives less than 0.002 millirem per year — far below natural background radiation. The key rule: never take the unit apart, crush it, or burn it, and never try to remove the americium source.
Best Route: Manufacturer Mail-Back
Both major makers run free consumer mail-back programs for ionization detectors (you pay only postage). First Alert accepts units branded First Alert, BRK, FamilyGard or Onelink — up to four at a time (call 1-800-323-9005 or see support.firstalert.com). Kidde accepts Kidde, Firex, Fyrnetics or Edwards units (including combination CO units): call 1-800-880-6788 first for a Return Authorization Number and the ship-to address. Remove the battery and ship by ground (not air). The NRC says household ionization detectors can also go in regular trash in most areas — but mail-back is preferred, and you must NOT trash them if your community incinerates its waste (they can trip radiation alarms).
Retailers, Battery & Combo Units
Don't count on stores: Home Depot, Lowe's and Best Buy generally don't take old smoke detectors, so use manufacturer mail-back or your local HHW facility. Always remove the battery first — for a 9-volt, tape the terminals (they can short and start a fire) and recycle it at a battery drop-off. For combination smoke + carbon-monoxide detectors, the CO part has no radioactive source; if the unit is also ionization, dispose of the whole thing through the ionization route after removing the battery.