It Depends on the Wrap
Plain, uncoated paper-based gift wrap is usually recyclable in curbside paper collection. But the EPA notes that paper gift wrap "often is not recyclable when it has a shiny or laminated coating." Anything foil or metallic, glittery, plastic-laminated/glossy, or heavily textured has to go in the trash. Tossing coated or glittered wrap in the bin can contaminate and ruin an entire load of otherwise good paper.
The Scrunch Test
Here's the quick way to check: crush the paper into a tight ball and let go. If it stays scrunched in a ball, it's most likely plain paper and recyclable. If it springs back toward flat, it has a plastic, wax or foil coating and belongs in the trash. Glitter is made of plastic, so any glittered wrap fails the test automatically.
What's Never Recyclable
Always remove and trash these before recycling the paper: tape, gift tags, bows and ribbons (ribbons never recycle, and long curly ribbon can jam sorting machines). Foil, metallic and glitter wrap go in the garbage. Tissue paper is usually not recyclable either — its fibers are too short to be remade into paper, and many programs don't take it. As always, confirm what your local program accepts.
For a plain-English breakdown of what the numbers and arrows mean, see our guide to recycling symbols and numbers.