Yes — If It's Clean
The EPA confirms aluminum foil can be recycled as long as you remove the food residue first. The problem is never the foil itself — it's the grease and stuck-on food. Foil coated in meat juice, fat or sauce can't be processed and goes in the trash. If you can wipe or lightly rinse it clean and dry, it's good to recycle. (Note foil is NOT compostable, so greasy foil doesn't belong in compost either.)
Scrunch It Into a Ball
Crumple your clean foil into a ball, combining several pieces into one wad at least about 2 inches across. Size matters: single flat sheets and little scraps slip through the screens at the sorting facility and are lost, while a 2-inch (or bigger) ball gets captured and sorted with the metals. The same goes for clean foil trays and pie pans — scrape them clean of food first.
Check Your Local Program
Aluminum foil often can't go in the curbside bin even though the metal is valuable — many transfer stations and scrap-metal recyclers take clean foil, and some curbside programs do too. If your program accepts foil, it usually also accepts clean foil trays and pans. When in doubt, confirm foil specifically with your local recycler, since some list it separately from cans.
Many people get this wrong — we bust the most common recycling myths in a separate guide.