Never Trash a Charged Extinguisher
A fire extinguisher that isn't completely empty is hazardous: the compressed cylinder can explode if crushed or incinerated. So never puncture, burn, or throw a pressurized extinguisher in the trash or recycling. If the gauge still reads in the charged (green) zone, the unit needs special handling — take it to a household hazardous waste (HHW) facility or a fire-equipment service company, both of which can handle a full cylinder. Only a fully emptied extinguisher is safe to recycle or, where allowed, discard.
Rechargeable vs. Disposable
Check the label and build. Rechargeable extinguishers have a sturdy metal valve head, a metal pressure gauge, and a label saying they're serviceable — these can be recharged and recertified by a certified fire-equipment company after use. Disposable (single-use) units are lighter, often with a plastic head and a 'dispose after use' label; they can't be refilled. Under the NFPA 10 standard, disposable extinguishers should be taken out of service 12 years after the manufacture date stamped on the cylinder, and rechargeable dry-chemical units get a hydrostatic test on a 12-year cycle.
How to Empty and Recycle It
To retire a usable-but-unwanted extinguisher yourself: take it outdoors to a well-ventilated open area, aim away from people, pets and anything flammable, and squeeze the lever to discharge all the agent. Let it sit a few days and recheck the gauge to confirm the pressure is fully gone. Then unscrew the head from the cylinder so a recycler can see it's empty — the steel cylinder and head can be recycled as scrap metal. The common ABC dry-chemical powder (monoammonium phosphate) is only a mild irritant, but avoid breathing it. If you'd rather not do this, a fire-equipment company or your HHW facility will depressurize it for you.
Where to Take It
Reliable drop-offs: a household hazardous waste (HHW) facility or collection event, a fire-equipment service/recharging company, and many local fire departments — but fire-department acceptance varies and some stations can't take used or expired units, so call the non-emergency line first. Big-box stores generally don't help: Home Depot has no take-back program and points customers to their local HHW facility or fire department. Use Earth911.com or your county solid-waste department to find a specific local option.